Effect of Binaural Beats and Isochronic Tones on Brain Wave Modulation

Introduction

Sound has long been recognized as a powerful influence on the human mind and body. In recent years, the scientific and technological communities have shown growing interest in how specific auditory stimuli, such as binaural beats and Isochronic tones, can modulate brain wave activity. Both techniques aim to alter neural-oscillations in the brain to induce states of relaxation, focus, or enhanced cognition.

Scientific Background

An example of this is the case of listening to a binaural beat of 10 Hz that the brain perceives when two tones in very slightly different frequencies are played in each ear independently (e.g. 114 Hz and 124 Hz). The cortical EEG activity is then synchronized with the frequency of 10 Hz by the neural circuitry (in the superior olivary nucleus of the brainstem). Due to this entrainment effect, the oscillations in the brain which are predominant are synchronized with the beat frequency - which in this case is the alpha band (8-12 Hz).

Conversely Isochronic tones are made by repeating one tone using a high on-off pulse at a steady rate. This creates a converging signal that strikes the brain into the desired frequency range without even the need to source ear inputs.

Both of these methods engage the brain in terms of tendency to external rhythms (commonly known as the frequency-following response), and may be applied to achieve a mental state by stimulating a specific EEG band.

Brainwave Frequency Bands

Brainwaves have five major frequency bands that have different cognitive correlates. As an example, alpha (8-12 Hz) waves are associated with alertness but not stress, whereas higher frequencies, such as beta (12-30 Hz) and gamma (>30 Hz) are associated with thinking and attention. The beats of music are meant to appeal to these bands. The activity in the brain is usually divided into frequency groups (delta, theta, alpha, beta, gamma), each of which is related to a particular mental state.

According to the example above, theta and delta waves (4 Hz and lower) are associated with drowsiness and deep sleep whereas alpha waves (8-12 Hz) are associated with a relaxed, reflective attention. Faster beta (13-30 Hz) and gamma (30-100 Hz) waves are linked to concentration, cognitive processing and high order awareness.

Entrainment methods tending to drive the predominant rhythm of the EEG to the band of a specific frequency by creating an audible beat in a preferred frequency. As an example, an alpha-wave activity, which can promote relaxation or meditative conditions, can be induced by creating a 10 Hz binaural beat.

Effect and Applications Reported

Based on the study, cognitive and mood alterations are measurable and can be reached by the aid of audio entrainment. It was demonstrated that many studies were improved in attention, memory or learning performance after specific beat. Indicatively, in a study it was found that isochronic-tone high-gamma stimulation (30-100 Hz) increased sustained attention scores during a vigilance test significantly after 10 minutes. The anecdotal and small-scale studies show that listeners report higher concentration or creativity when the listener is in beta/gamma stimulation (associated with alertness).

• Concentration and Cognitive Performance: The Controlled trials have revealed that beta/gamma-frequency entrainment, has the ability to sharpen the mind. It is significant that the Jakarta study, in which 10 minutes of isochronic tones with gamma range enhanced the task performance and focus scores of students, significantly.

• Relaxation and Mood: Lower-frequency stimulation has been found to cause relaxation. As an illustration, one-minute acute efforts of isochronic pulses (6, 10 and 40 Hz) acutely reduced anxiety and improved mood in healthy adults. Also, there was a long-term intervention, which showed that daily auditory entrainment also had a significant positive effect on the quality of sleep and reduced stress/anxiety scores in college students.

• Potential therapeutic utility: Previous research has depicted positive outcomes in a broad spectrum of disorders. The systematic review can conclude that entrainment has the capability to modify mood and cognitive processing in CNS disorder: the findings were that it improved the subjects with ADHD, chronic pain, epilepsy, Parkinson disease and anxiety disorders.

Nevertheless, the non-significant or less pronounced effects are often witnessed in healthy controls. It is worth noting that none of these trials have reported any adverse effects, which is an indication that auditory entrainment is most likely to be safe when used properly. Even though this has positive outcomes, critics caution that a majority of the research is methodologically flawed. A single review of 33 studies determined that merely 17 studies were of superior quality and that the colossal majority of them involved the use of binaural beats and not isochronic tones.

Moreover, not every study indicates any significant findings: in some experiments, no significant findings of the short-term exposure to binaural-beat effects on the reaction times and working memory were found. By so doing, a positive tendency exists albeit with further serious studies capable of supporting the specific effects and the most optimal parameters.

Isochronic Tones vs. Binaural Beats

Isochronic tones have stronger chances of creating strong entrainments in comparison. One of these reviews' further states that when the same was done under similar conditions with the use of isochronic stimulation, the cortical modulation was approximately 15 percent higher when done with the use of binaural beats. It may be because the onset and the offset pulses of isochronic tones are stronger to the neurons. Recent isochronic beats, e.g. of gamma tonic frequency have been shown to have a major positive effect on attention and cognitive performance.

Binaural beats do, however, alter brainwaves, but perhaps it will require a more precise arrangement (good headphones, regular listening) to be effective. In practice, either of the two can be experimented with: an isochronic version of the same frequency is the common choice when a binaural track does not cause any inconvenience to the user.

Professional Practice and Self-Assessment

In the attempt to implement such techniques in the absence of the equipment, several challenges are encountered. The generation of the desired frequencies requires proper audio devices or programs and good headphones require proper separation of stereo (to hear binaural beats). Background noises and individual differences (e.g. hearing ability) have the potential to mitigate the entrainment effect. Moreover, the perceived gains are often immeasurable and subjective and the effects are hard to prove unless one uses EEG.

The period of the practice was also difficult because I was unable to maintain the conditions of listening under the same conditions and the effects of the beats were impossible to differentiate compared to the placebo. The issue of time constraints and result confirmation was also present. The subjective observations will be discussed further as they will be applied to the real-life experience.

Conclusion

In short, binaural beats and isochronic tones provide a neuroscientifically supported way of changing the activity of the brainwaves. Based on scientific research, it has been demonstrated that listening to such audio stimuli actually can alter EEG patterns to the target frequency band and induce the changes in cognition or mood.

The techniques have been reported to have beneficial effects such as improvement in attention, relaxation and some clinical symptoms, are non-invasive and seem to be safe. Nevertheless, the impact might be affected by people differently, and most results are still in their initial stages. One of the important conclusions to be made concerns the fact that brainwave entrainment has a potential, but more serious studies should be carried out to completely justify and maximize its application. One should be ready to speak about the known science of auditory entrainment and respond to detailed questions concerning the manner of working and its reasons.

About the Author

References